Artificial Color (Red 40)additiveWorth knowing about
Artificial food coloring dyes like Red 40 are used primarily for visual appeal to pet owners, not pets. Some studies suggest potential sensitivities, and they offer no nutritional benefit.
Also appears on labels as: artificial color, red 40
Source: FDA, AAFCO
Artificial ColorscolorWorth knowing about
Artificial dyes (like Yellow 5, Red 40, Blue 1) are synthetic colorants.
Added to make the food look more appealing to pet owners (not for pets themselves).
Artificial colors are approved by the FDA for pet foods, but many owners and nutritionists question whether they are necessary or desirable. Pets do not need colored food—this is purely for human visual appeal. Some studies suggest artificial dyes may contribute to behavioral issues in sensitive individuals (in people), though evidence in pets is limited. Premium and natural brands typically avoid artificial colors in favor of natural colorants. Avoiding artificial dyes is a simple way to reduce unnecessary additives.
Also appears on labels as: artificial dye, artificial dyes, colorants (artificial), colorants (artificial dyes), added color, added colors, colorants
Source: FDA (food coloring regulations); AAFCO
B
BarleygrainNeutral
Digestible whole grain providing carbohydrates and fiber. A legitimate grain ingredient with nutritional value, though less common than rice or oatmeal in pet foods.
Source: AAFCO
BeefproteinGenerally beneficial
Named beef protein that is easily digestible and species-appropriate. A quality indicator in pet foods, commonly used as a primary protein source.
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
BHApreservativeWe score this down
BHA (butylated hydroxyanisole) is an antioxidant preservative.
Used to prevent fats from turning rancid, extending shelf life.
BHA is legal in US pet food and generally recognized as safe in animal feed at low levels (total antioxidants no more than 0.02% of the fat). It is also one of the most questioned preservatives: the US National Toxicology Program lists it as reasonably anticipated to be a human carcinogen, based on animal studies, and in February 2026 FDA began a formal safety reassessment of BHA in human food. No decision has been made. Many pet foods now use natural preservation instead, such as mixed tocopherols (a form of vitamin E) or rosemary extract.
Also appears on labels as: animal fat (bha preserved), animal fat (bha-bht preserved), butylated hydroxyanisole, bha
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 582.3169 (BHA, generally recognized as safe in animal feed), US National Toxicology Program, Report on Carcinogens: butylated hydroxyanisole, FDA, FDA Launches Assessment of BHA, a Common Food Chemical Preservative (10 Feb 2026)
BHTpreservativeWe score this down
BHT (butylated hydroxytoluene) is an antioxidant preservative.
Used to prevent fats from turning rancid, extending shelf life.
BHT is legal in US pet food and generally recognized as safe in animal feed at low levels (total antioxidants no more than 0.02% of the fat). In May 2026 FDA announced a reassessment of BHT's safety in human food. No decision has been made. Natural alternatives such as mixed tocopherols and rosemary extract are widely used instead.
Also appears on labels as: beef fat (bha/bht preserved), bha/bht preserved, butylated hydroxytoluene, bht
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 582.3173 (BHT, generally recognized as safe in animal feed), FDA, FDA Finalizes Food Chemical Safety Post-Market Assessment Program, Launches Reassessment of BHT, ADA (12 May 2026)
BiotinvitaminGenerally beneficial
B vitamin supporting skin and coat health. Often included for its role in maintaining healthy skin and preventing hair loss.
Also appears on labels as: vitamin b7, vitamin h
Source: AAFCO, FDA
BlueberriesadditiveGenerally beneficial
Whole fruit ingredient providing antioxidants, fiber, and nutrients. A quality ingredient that supports overall health and immunity in pets.
Source: AAFCO
Brown RicegrainNeutral
Digestible carbohydrate source providing fiber and nutrients. A wholesome grain ingredient superior to refined white rice in nutritional value.
Also appears on labels as: rice
Source: AAFCO
By-Products of Plant OriginadditiveNeutral
"by-products of plant origin" refers to secondary materials or left-over parts from processing plants, grains, fruits, and vegetables for human use. These components provide dietary fiber, essential carbohydrates, or auxiliary proteins instead of serving as primary meat ingredient
Also appears on labels as: sous-produits d'origine végétale, vegetable by-products
Source: FEDIAF
C
Calcium CarbonatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing calcium, essential for bone development and muscle function. Ensures proper calcium-phosphorus balance in complete and balanced formulas.
Also appears on labels as: limestone
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Calcium IodatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing iodine, essential for thyroid function and metabolism. Ensures proper thyroid hormone production; included in controlled amounts.
Also appears on labels as: iodine
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Calcium PantothenatevitaminGenerally beneficial
B vitamin (Vitamin B5) supporting energy production and stress response. Important for metabolism and immune system function.
Also appears on labels as: calcium pantothenate, d-calcium pantothenate, vitamin b5, Calcium Pantothenate (Vitamin B5)
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Cane MolassessweetenerWorth knowing about
A thick syrup left over from refining sugar.
Adds sweetness and helps bind treats and biscuits.
Molasses is an added sugar. Pets do not need added sugar, which is why FurMetric marks it down. It is most common in treats.
Also appears on labels as: cane molasses, molasses, beet molasses
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for cane molasses
Caramel ColorcolorNeutral
Caramel color is made by heating sugars to create a brown pigment.
Creates a brown color without artificial dyes.
Caramel color is approved by the FDA and is derived from natural sugar. It is one of the safer coloring options and is common in natural/premium brands. It does not carry the same concerns as synthetic dyes. Regulatory agencies consider it safe for pets at approved levels.
Also appears on labels as: caramel color, colorante caramelo, caramel coloring, class iv caramel color
Source: FDA (color additives); AAFCO
CarrageenanthickenerWorth knowing about
Carrageenan is a thickening agent derived from red seaweed.
Creates the gel texture in wet/canned foods.
Carrageenan is derived from seaweed and is FDA-approved for pet foods. It is a natural thickener commonly used in wet foods. Some debate exists about potential digestive concerns (particularly regarding inflammation), but regulatory agencies maintain it is safe at approved levels for most pets.
Also appears on labels as: carrageenan, carrageenan (thickener), carrageenan gum
Source: FDA (food additive status); AAFCO
CarrotsadditiveGenerally beneficial
Whole vegetable ingredient providing fiber, vitamins, and natural sweetness. A wholesome, nutrient-dense ingredient common in quality pet foods.
Source: AAFCO
ChickenproteinGenerally beneficial
Named poultry protein source that is highly digestible and species-appropriate for dogs and cats. Fresh named meats indicate quality and transparency in formulations.
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
Chicken (Named Meat)proteinGenerally beneficial
Named meat sources like chicken are high-quality, species-appropriate protein that pets digest efficiently. Using specific meat names (rather than "meat" or "poultry") indicates transparency and quality.
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
Chicken FatfatGenerally beneficial
Animal fat providing essential fatty acids for coat and skin health. Preserved with natural vitamin E (mixed tocopherols) rather than synthetic preservatives.
Also appears on labels as: chicken fat, preserved with mixed tocopherols, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols)
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
Chicken MealproteinNeutral
Rendered chicken protein, more concentrated than fresh chicken. A legitimate protein source; fresh named meats are generally preferred in premium formulas.
Source: AAFCO
Choline ChloridevitaminGenerally beneficial
Nutrient supporting brain development and liver function. Essential for cognitive function and metabolic health in dogs and cats.
Also appears on labels as: choline
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Copper Amino Acid ChelatenutrientNeutral
Mineral providing bioavailable copper, essential for iron metabolism and coat color. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more bioavailable than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Copper ProteinatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing bioavailable copper, essential for iron metabolism and coat color. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more bioavailable than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Copper SulfatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing copper, essential for iron metabolism and coat color. Sulfate forms are less bioavailable than proteinate or amino acid chelate forms.
Also appears on labels as: copper sulphate
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Corn Gluten MealproteinWorth knowing about
The protein-rich part of corn left after the starch is removed during milling. Labels increasingly call it corn protein meal.
A cheap way to raise protein content.
Like pea protein, it raises the crude protein figure without coming from meat, which is why FurMetric marks it down when it appears high in the list.
Also appears on labels as: corn gluten meal, corn protein meal, corn gluten, corn protein
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for corn gluten meal
Corn SyrupadditiveWorth knowing about
Corn syrup is a sweetener that adds unnecessary sugar to pet food. While not toxic, it can contribute to weight gain and dental problems in pets when used excessively.
Also appears on labels as: glucose syrup
Source: AAFCO
CranberriesadditiveGenerally beneficial
Whole fruit ingredient providing antioxidants and fiber. Traditionally associated with urinary tract health in pets, though research on efficacy is mixed.
Source: AAFCO
D
DL-Methionineamino acidGenerally beneficial
Essential amino acid supporting immune function and urinary health. Often added to formulas to ensure complete amino acid profiles and support urinary pH management.
Also appears on labels as: dl methionine, methionine
Beneficial bacteria supporting digestive and immune health. Produces short-chain fatty acids that nourish the intestinal lining and support overall gut health.
Also appears on labels as: bifidobacterium longum
Source: AAFCO
Dried Chicory RootproduceNeutral
Plant ingredient providing inulin, a prebiotic fiber supporting digestive health. Encourages beneficial bacteria growth in the gut and supports overall digestive function.
Also appears on labels as: chicory, chicory root, inulin
Source: AAFCO
Dried Egg ProductproteinGenerally beneficial
Concentrated egg protein source that provides amino acids and nutrients. A quality ingredient, though whole eggs are occasionally preferred in premium foods.
Source: AAFCO
Dried KelpmineralGenerally beneficial
Seaweed ingredient providing minerals, iodine, and nutrients. Used to support overall health; should be included in modest amounts as excessive iodine can be problematic.
Beneficial bacteria supporting digestive health and nutrient absorption. Helps maintain healthy gut microbiome and can reduce digestive upset in sensitive pets.
Also appears on labels as: lactobacillus acidophilus
Beneficial bacteria supporting digestive health and immune function. Helps balance gut flora and supports nutrient absorption from food.
Also appears on labels as: pediococcus acidilactici
Source: AAFCO
Dried Tomato PomaceproduceNeutral
A safe, common by-product of tomato processing made from leftover skins, pulp, and crushed seeds. Used primarily as a healthy, natural source of dietary fiber and antioxidants like lycopene, it helps firm up stool and supports good digestion
Also appears on labels as: tomato pomace
Source: AAFCO
Dried YeastadditiveNeutral
Fermented yeast product providing B vitamins, minerals, and amino acids. A nutritious ingredient that supports immune function and coat health.
Also appears on labels as: brewers dried yeast, yeast
Source: AAFCO
E
EthoxyquinpreservativeWe score this down
Ethoxyquin is a synthetic antioxidant preservative.
Used to preserve fats and prevent spoilage in ingredients and finished foods.
Ethoxyquin is a synthetic antioxidant that stops fats going rancid, often added to fish meal before it reaches the pet food maker. It is permitted in US animal feed, and in US human food only in a few spices such as paprika and chili powder. The European Union suspended it as a feed additive in 2017 and formally refused it in 2022, because its safety could not be established.
Also appears on labels as: santoquin, ethoxyquin
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 573.380 (ethoxyquin in animal feeds), FDA, 21 CFR 172.140 (ethoxyquin in human food: chili powder, paprika, ground chili), European Commission, Implementing Regulations (EU) 2017/962 and 2022/1375
F
Ferrous SulfatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing iron, essential for oxygen transport in blood. Sulfate forms are less efficiently absorbed than proteinate or amino acid chelate forms.
Also appears on labels as: iron (ii) sulfate, iron sulfate
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Fish MealproteinGenerally beneficial
Rendered fish protein rich in amino acids. A nutritious protein source commonly used in pet foods, particularly beneficial for omega-3 content.
Also appears on labels as: ocean fish meal
Source: AAFCO
Fish OilnutrientGenerally beneficial
Natural source of omega-3 fatty acids supporting coat and skin health. Similar benefits to salmon oil but may be from various fish species.
Source: AAFCO
FlaxseedfatGenerally beneficial
Plant-based source of omega-3 fatty acids and fiber. Supports coat and skin health, though marine sources (fish oil) are generally more bioavailable for pets.
Also appears on labels as: flax seed, ground flaxseed, linseed
Source: AAFCO
Folic AcidvitaminGenerally beneficial
B vitamin (Vitamin B9) supporting cell division and DNA synthesis. Critical for proper growth and development, especially in growing puppies and kittens.
Also appears on labels as: folate, vitamin b9
Source: AAFCO, FDA
G
GlycerinadditiveWorth knowing about
A clear, slightly sweet liquid, usually made from vegetable oils.
Keeps soft treats and chews moist and chewy, and helps them last longer.
Glycerin is generally recognized as safe in animal feed. It adds texture rather than nutrition, which is why FurMetric gives it a small deduction. It is most common in soft treats and jerky-style products.
Also appears on labels as: vegetable glycerin, glycerine, glycerol, coconut glycerin, vegetable glycerine
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 582.1320 (glycerin, generally recognized as safe in animal feed)
Guar GumthickenerNeutral
Guar gum is a thickening agent derived from guar beans.
Creates consistency in wet foods; acts as a binder and thickener.
Guar gum is derived from beans and is a natural thickener approved by the FDA. It is widely used in premium pet foods and is generally well-tolerated. A legitimate alternative to carrageenan for pets sensitive to seaweed-based thickeners.
Also appears on labels as: guar, guar gum 0.2%, guaran, guar gum
Source: FDA (natural food additive); AAFCO
I
Iron Amino Acid ChelatenutrientNeutral
Mineral providing bioavailable iron, essential for oxygen transport in blood. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more efficiently absorbed than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Iron Oxide ColorcolorNeutral
Iron oxide is a mineral pigment (rust) used for coloring.
Provides brown, red, or yellow tones without synthetic organic dyes.
Iron oxide is an FDA-approved mineral colorant. It is inert (does not react in the digestive system) and is considered safe. This is a mineral-based alternative to synthetic dyes, used in some natural and premium brands.
Also appears on labels as: iron oxide color, iron oxide (colorant), iron oxides
Source: FDA (food coloring regulations); AAFCO
Iron ProteinatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing bioavailable iron, essential for oxygen transport in blood. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more efficiently absorbed than sulfate forms.
Stabilized form of Vitamin C supporting immune function and antioxidant protection. More stable than regular vitamin C in pet food formulations.
Also appears on labels as: ascorbic acid, l-ascorbyl-2-polyphosphate, source of vitamin c, vitamin c, L-Ascorbyl-2-Polyphosphate (source of Vitamin C)
Source: AAFCO, FDA
LambproteinGenerally beneficial
Lamb is a high-quality, named meat protein source that is easily digestible and appropriate for dogs and cats. It is a good choice for pets with sensitivities to poultry.
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
Lamb MealproteinNeutral
Lamb meal is rendered lamb protein, more concentrated than fresh lamb meat. It is a legitimate and nutritious protein source commonly used in quality pet foods.
Source: AAFCO
M
Manganese Amino Acid ChelatenutrientNeutral
Mineral providing manganese, essential for bone development and metabolic function. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms provide better absorption than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Manganese ProteinatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing manganese, essential for bone development and metabolic function. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms provide better absorption than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Manganese SulfatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing manganese, essential for bone development and metabolic function. Sulfate forms provide less absorption than proteinate or amino acid chelate forms.
Also appears on labels as: manganese sulphate
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Meat By-ProductsproteinWorth knowing about
Meat by-products are the clean parts of slaughtered animals other than the muscle meat, such as organs. They exclude hair, horns, teeth and hooves. Nutritious, but less specific than a named meat.
Also appears on labels as: meat byproducts, byproduct, by-products, by-product, animal by-products
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for meat by-products
Menadione (Vitamin K3)vitaminWorth knowing about
A synthetic form of vitamin K.
Vitamin K is needed for normal blood clotting. Menadione is a cheap, stable way to add it.
Menadione is permitted in US animal feed as a source of vitamin K, and FDA lists approved forms in its feed additive regulations. It is controversial because it is a synthetic compound rather than the natural forms of vitamin K, and some brands choose to leave it out. The amounts used in pet food are small. FurMetric gives it a small deduction as a synthetic additive that some foods manage without.
Also appears on labels as: menadione, menadione sodium bisulfite complex, menadione sodium bisulphite complex, msbc, menadione nicotinamide bisulfite, menadione dimethylpyrimidinol bisulfite, vitamin k3, source of vitamin k activity
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 573.620 and 573.625 (menadione forms permitted as feed additives)
Mixed TocopherolspreservativeGenerally beneficial
Mixed tocopherols are natural forms of vitamin E.
Used as a natural antioxidant to prevent fats from spoiling and maintain freshness.
Mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) are a natural preservative extracted from vegetable oils. Like BHA and BHT, tocopherols are generally recognized as safe in animal feed; unlike them, they are a natural form of vitamin E, the same form found in supplements for people. This is a common sign of a naturally preserved formula. Products preserved this way often have a shorter shelf life once opened.
Also appears on labels as: mixed tocopherols (preservative), natural mixed tocopherols, tocopherol, vitamin e, vitamin e (tocopherol), mixed tocopherols
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 582.3890 (tocopherols, generally recognized as safe in animal feed)
Montmorillonite ClayadditiveNeutral
A natural clay mineral. Bentonite is made mostly of montmorillonite.
Used as a binder to hold kibble and pellets together, and to stop dry ingredients clumping.
Bentonite is generally recognized as safe in animal feed. It contributes no nutrition. Its job is texture and flow during manufacturing.
Also appears on labels as: montmorillonite, bentonite, sodium bentonite, calcium montmorillonite
Source: FDA, 21 CFR 582.1155 (bentonite, generally recognized as safe in animal feed)
N
Natural FlavorflavorNeutral
Natural flavors are compounds extracted from plant or animal sources.
Make food more palatable so pets eat it.
Natural flavors are derived from real ingredients (meat, herbs, etc.) rather than synthetic chemicals. The term "natural flavor" is regulated by the FDA and requires derivation from natural sources. This is a common, safe ingredient in all quality pet foods. "Natural" here means the source is nature-derived, not that it is minimally processed—the compounds are typically isolated and concentrated.
B vitamin (Vitamin B3) supporting energy metabolism and skin health. Essential for converting food into energy and maintaining healthy skin and coat.
Also appears on labels as: niacin, niacinamide, vitamin b3
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Nicotinic AcidnutrientNeutral
B vitamin (Vitamin B3) supporting energy metabolism and skin health. Essential for converting food into energy and maintaining healthy skin and coat.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
O
OatmealgrainNeutral
Digestible grain providing carbohydrates, fiber, and some protein. A wholesome ingredient commonly used in pet foods and can support digestive health.
Also appears on labels as: ground oatmeal, oats
Source: AAFCO
Organic BeetsproduceNeutral
Safe, healthy additions to pet food in moderation. They provide valuable dietary fiber, vitamins (like Vitamin C), and antioxidants that support digestion, skin, and immune health
Also appears on labels as: beet, beets
Source: AAFCO, FDA
P
Pantothenic AcidnutrientNeutral
B vitamin (Vitamin B5) supporting energy production and stress response. Important for metabolism and immune system function.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Pea ProteinproteinWorth knowing about
Protein extracted from peas and concentrated into a powder.
An inexpensive way to raise a food's protein content, and a binder in kibble.
The crude protein percentage on a label counts protein from every source. Pea protein can lift that number while the food contains less meat than the figure suggests, which is why FurMetric marks it down when it appears near the top of the list. Pea protein is also among the pulse ingredients named in FDA's investigation into diet and heart disease in dogs. See the Peas, Lentils & Other Legumes entry for what FDA did and did not conclude.
Also appears on labels as: pea protein concentrate, pea protein isolate, pea protein, dried pea protein
Source: FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine, FDA Investigation into Potential Link between Certain Diets and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy (last updated 23 Dec 2022) - names pulses in various forms, including protein
Peas, Lentils & Other LegumesproduceNeutral
Peas, lentils, chickpeas and beans are legumes (also called pulses): seeds that are high in carbohydrate and fiber and contain a fair amount of plant protein.
They supply energy, fiber and protein, and they replace grains in grain-free foods. Their protein also raises the crude protein figure printed on the bag.
Legumes are not harmful in themselves, and FurMetric does not score a food down simply for containing them. A recipe can lose points when legumes dominate the top of the ingredient list, because they then stand in for animal protein, which counts for more in our scoring. You may have heard legumes linked to heart disease in dogs. In 2018 the FDA began investigating reports of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs eating diets with peas, lentils, other pulses or potatoes as main ingredients. In its update of 23 December 2022, FDA said the reports did not by themselves establish a causal link, that the issue may involve multiple factors, and that it would not post further updates until there is meaningful new scientific information. Research continues and the question is not settled. If you have concerns about your dog's heart or diet, talk to your veterinarian.
Also appears on labels as: peas, green peas, pea, lentils, red lentils, green lentils, chickpeas, garbanzo beans, beans, legumes, legume, pulses, pea flour, pea fiber, pea starch, legume heavy, legume load
Source: FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine, FDA Investigation into Potential Link between Certain Diets and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy (last updated 23 Dec 2022), Freeman LM, Stern JA, Fries R, Adin DB, Rush JE. Diet-associated dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs: what do we know? J Am Vet Med Assoc, 2018, volume 253, pages 1390-1394.
Potassium ChloridemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing potassium, essential for heart function and muscle contractions. Added to balance sodium and support cardiovascular health.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Potassium IodidemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing iodine, essential for thyroid health and metabolic function. Similar function to calcium iodate but in different chemical form.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Potatoes & Potato ProductsproduceNeutral
Potatoes in various forms: whole, dried, starch or concentrated protein.
A carbohydrate and binder, common in grain-free kibble.
Potatoes are a normal food ingredient. They are also named in FDA's investigation into diet and heart disease in dogs, alongside peas, lentils and other pulses. See the Peas, Lentils & Other Legumes entry for what FDA did and did not conclude.
Also appears on labels as: potatoes, potato, dried potatoes, potato starch, potato protein, potato flakes
Source: FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine, FDA Investigation into Potential Link between Certain Diets and Canine Dilated Cardiomyopathy (last updated 23 Dec 2022)
Poultry By-Product MealproteinWorth knowing about
A rendered, dried protein made from parts of the poultry carcass other than the main meat, such as necks, feet, undeveloped eggs and organs. Feathers are excluded.
An inexpensive, concentrated source of animal protein.
By-products are not bad by nature. Organs such as liver are highly nutritious. FurMetric marks them down because the mix of parts can vary from batch to batch and 'poultry' does not say which bird it came from, so the label tells you less than a named meat or meal does.
Also appears on labels as: poultry by-product meal, poultry byproduct meal, poultry by-products, chicken by-product meal, chicken byproduct meal
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for poultry by-product meal
Powdered CelluloseadditiveWorth knowing about
Purified plant fiber, often made from wood pulp.
Adds fiber and bulk without calories, common in weight-control and hairball foods.
It has a real purpose in reduced-calorie foods, but it provides no nutrients, so FurMetric gives it a small deduction when it is used as bulk.
Also appears on labels as: cellulose, powdered cellulose, cellulose powder
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for powdered cellulose
ProbioticsnutrientGenerally beneficial
Probiotics are beneficial live bacteria that support digestive health and nutrient absorption. They help maintain a healthy gut microbiome and can reduce digestive upset.
Also appears on labels as: dried fermentation products, live cultures
Source: AAFCO
Propylene GlycolpreservativeWe score this down
Propylene glycol is a humectant and preservative used in wet foods.
Keeps moisture in canned/wet foods, prevents mold growth, maintains texture.
Propylene glycol is FDA-approved for use in pet foods. However, it is PROHIBITED in cat food (21 CFR 589.1001) by the FDA due to concerns about hemolytic anemia in cats. In dog foods at approved levels, it is considered safe by regulatory agencies. If you own a cat, avoid any product containing propylene glycol. The rulebook auto-fails any cat food with this ingredient.
Also appears on labels as: propylene glycol, propylene-glycol
Source: FDA (21 CFR 589.1001, 573.780); FDA CVM guidance
PumpkinproduceNeutral
Whole vegetable rich in fiber and nutrients. Commonly used to support digestive health and can help with both constipation and diarrhea in pets.
B vitamin (Vitamin B6) supporting amino acid metabolism and immune function. Important for proper protein utilization and immune response.
Also appears on labels as: pyridoxine hydrochloride (vitamin b6)
Source: AAFCO, FDA
R
Riboflavin SupplementvitaminGenerally beneficial
B vitamin (Vitamin B2) supporting energy production and cell growth. Essential for converting food into usable energy.
Also appears on labels as: riboflavin, vitamin b2
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Rosemary ExtractpreservativeGenerally beneficial
Rosemary extract is a natural antioxidant derived from rosemary herb.
Used as a natural preservative to prevent fat rancidity without synthetic chemicals.
Rosemary extract contains natural antioxidants (carnosic acid) that slow spoilage. It is GRAS (Generally Recognized as Safe) for pet foods and is a popular choice among premium and natural brands. Note: this is different from the rosemary herb itself (which can be toxic to dogs in large quantities); the extract is processed differently and safe at approved levels.
Also appears on labels as: rosemary extract, rosemary oleoresin, natural preservatives (rosemary)
Source: FDA (GRAS determination); AAFCO
S
Salmon OilnutrientGenerally beneficial
Salmon oil is a rich natural source of omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), which support skin health, coat quality, and immune function in dogs and cats.
Also appears on labels as: fish oil (salmon)
Source: AAFCO, WSAVA
SaltnutrientNeutral
Mineral providing sodium and chloride, essential electrolytes for nerve and muscle function. Included in controlled amounts to maintain proper electrolyte balance.
Source: AAFCO
Sodium SelenitemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing selenium, a powerful antioxidant supporting immune function and thyroid health. Essential in small amounts; excess can be problematic.
Also appears on labels as: selenium
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Soybean MealproteinNeutral
Ground soybeans left after the oil has been pressed out.
An inexpensive plant protein.
A useful protein source, but plant protein counts for less than animal protein in FurMetric's scoring, so foods that rely on it near the top of the list score lower.
Also appears on labels as: soybean meal, soy meal, dehulled soybean meal, soy flour, soy protein, soybean protein
Source: AAFCO Official Publication, ingredient definition for soybean meal
SugarsweetenerWorth knowing about
Sugars are simple carbohydrates from sugar cane, beets, or corn.
Added sweetness and palatability; acts as a binder.
Sugar is FDA-approved and safe for dogs at typical levels, but adds calories without nutrition. High sugar intake is linked to obesity and dental disease in pets. Cats are obligate carnivores and do not have taste receptors for sweetness, making added sugar particularly unnecessary in cat foods. The rulebook includes a deduction for added sugars depending on prominence in the formula.
Also appears on labels as: sugar, cane sugar, organic cane sugar, various sugars, sugars
Source: AAFCO; WSAVA nutrition guidelines
T
TaurinenutrientGenerally beneficial
Taurine is an amino acid essential for cats.
Added to ensure cats meet their taurine requirement.
Taurine is absolutely essential for cats—deficiency causes dilated cardiomyopathy (heart disease) and blindness. Dogs can synthesize their own taurine, but cats cannot. All quality commercial cat foods must contain adequate taurine. The rulebook awards a credit (+8) for taurine in cat foods.
B vitamin (Vitamin B1) supporting energy metabolism and nervous system function. Essential for converting carbohydrates into energy.
Also appears on labels as: thiamine, thiamine mononitrate, vitamin b1, Thiamine Mononitrate (Vitamin B1)
Source: AAFCO, FDA
TocopherolspreservativeGenerally beneficial
Natural vitamin E compounds used as preservatives. A safe, natural alternative to synthetic preservatives like BHA and BHT for maintaining food freshness.
Also appears on labels as: preservative, tocopherols, tocopherols (preservative)
Source: AAFCO, FDA
V
Vegetable Juice / Beet JuicecolorNeutral
Naturally-derived pigments from vegetable and fruit juices.
Provides color using whole-food sources instead of synthetic dyes.
Vegetable and beet juice colors are extracted from plants and represent a more natural coloring option than synthetic dyes. They are generally safe and approved by the FDA. This approach reflects a philosophy of minimal processing and whole-food sourcing, even though the visual color is still primarily for human appeal.
Also appears on labels as: vegetable color, fruit juice color, vegetable juice color, vegetable juice, beet juice color, beet juice (for color), vegetable juice (color), vegetable juice for color
Source: FDA (food coloring regulations); AAFCO
Vitamin A SupplementvitaminGenerally beneficial
Essential vitamin supporting vision, immune function, and skin health. Added to pet foods to ensure adequate levels across all life stages.
Also appears on labels as: retinol, retinyl acetate, vitamin a
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Vitamin B12 SupplementvitaminGenerally beneficial
B vitamin supporting energy metabolism and nervous system function. Important for pets' cognitive function and metabolic health.
Also appears on labels as: cobalamin, cyanocobalamin, vitamin b12
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Vitamin D3 SupplementvitaminGenerally beneficial
Essential vitamin supporting bone health and calcium absorption. Added to pet foods to ensure proper calcium-phosphorus balance and skeletal development.
Also appears on labels as: cholecalciferol, vitamin d, vitamin d3
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Vitamin E SupplementvitaminGenerally beneficial
Antioxidant vitamin supporting immune function and coat health. Also used as a natural preservative; essential for all pets' health and longevity.
Also appears on labels as: alpha tocopherol, dl-alpha tocopherol acetate
Source: AAFCO, FDA
W
Whole Grain Brown RiceadditiveNeutral
Whole grain brown rice is a digestible carbohydrate source that provides fiber and nutrients. It is a legitimate grain ingredient, superior to refined white rice in nutritional value.
Source: AAFCO
Y
Yucca Schidigera ExtractadditiveNeutral
Natural plant extract traditionally used to reduce odors in pet waste. Used as a natural digestive aid; generally recognized as safe in modest amounts.
Also appears on labels as: yucca, yucca schidigera
Source: AAFCO
Z
Zinc Amino Acid ChelatenutrientNeutral
Mineral providing zinc, essential for immune function and skin health. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more bioavailable than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Zinc ProteinatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing zinc, essential for immune function and skin health. Proteinate and amino acid chelate forms are more bioavailable than sulfate forms.
Source: AAFCO, FDA
Zinc SulfatemineralGenerally beneficial
Mineral providing zinc, essential for immune function and skin health. Sulfate forms are less bioavailable than proteinate or amino acid chelate forms.